6 Common Myths About Supported Independent Living

The hesitation is understandable. Maybe you've heard something that made you uncertain, or a story from another family that left you wondering whether Supported Independent Living (SIL) is really right for your family member. Maybe you're not sure they'd even qualify, or you're worried it might make things worse rather than better.

These concerns are real. They're also, in many cases, rooted in outdated information or common misunderstandings about how SIL actually works under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). This post addresses the six supported independent living myths we hear most often from families, and the honest facts behind each one. For a full introduction to what SIL is, see our complete introduction to Supported Independent Living.

Myth 1: You Need to Be Almost Independent Before Applying for SIL

This one stops a lot of families from even asking the question.

The myth goes like this: SIL is for people who are nearly self-sufficient and just need a little extra help. If your family member needs significant support to get through the day, they're probably not eligible.

The reality is the opposite. Supported Independent Living eligibility is assessed based on significant and ongoing daily support needs. The National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) looks at your family member's functional capacity and what support is "reasonable and necessary" for them to live well. SIL is not a reward for achieving independence; it exists specifically for people who need ongoing help with daily tasks.

This is also not a decision PDH or any housing provider makes. An occupational therapist and NDIA planner assess whether SIL is appropriate based on your family member's individual needs and circumstances. If your family member has high support needs and you've been assuming they don't qualify, it's worth talking to your support coordinator. Our SIL Readiness Checklist is a good place to start that conversation with yourself before you go further.

Myth 2: SIL Will Take Away Your Family Member's Independence

This fear comes from somewhere real. Many families have seen older models of disability housing, where people were placed into settings with little control over their environment, their schedule, or who cared for them. That history matters, and the worry it creates is legitimate.

Modern SIL is specifically designed to build and maintain independence, not reduce it. Support workers assist with tasks your family member cannot manage alone. They don't take over tasks your family member can handle. If someone can prepare their own breakfast but needs support with personal care, the SIL support reflects that exactly.

Your family member's goals, preferences, and routines drive the support plan. This isn't just a policy statement; it's a condition of how SIL services must operate under the NDIS. Consider a person who uses a wheelchair for mobility but has full cognitive capacity and a clear sense of how they want their day to run. Their SIL support worker assists with physical tasks on their direction. The participant is still in charge.

If you're worried about this, it's worth asking potential SIL providers directly how they handle participant choice and control. The answer tells you a lot.

Myth 3: SIL and SDA Are the Same Thing

This is probably the most common source of confusion, and it's not surprising given how similar the acronyms sound.

Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) is the physical home: a purpose-built dwelling with specialist design features that meet NDIS standards. SIL is the support funding: the people who help your family member with daily tasks inside their home. They are two entirely separate funding lines in an NDIS plan.

You can have SDA without SIL. You can have SIL without SDA. Many people have both, particularly those with high physical support needs who live in purpose-built properties.

This distinction matters practically. At Paramount Disability Homes, we provide SDA housing only. We are not a SIL provider. Your family member would choose their SIL provider separately, which is actually an advantage: there's no conflict of interest between who manages the home and who delivers the care. For a full breakdown of how these two supports differ, and when you might need one or both, see the SDA vs SIL Complete Comparison Guide.

One specific misconception worth naming: SIL funding does not cover rent, food, or utility bills. Those are separate costs, which brings us to the next myth.

Myth 4: SIL Covers Everything, Including Rent and Bills

Families are sometimes surprised to discover that SIL is not a comprehensive, all-in package. The assumption is understandable: if your family member has SIL funding, surely housing and living expenses are covered too?

SIL funding covers support worker costs only. According to the NDIS guidelines on what SIL includes and excludes, rent, food, utilities, phone bills, and other day-to-day expenses are not covered by SIL. Participants typically pay rent and living costs from the Disability Support Pension and rent assistance.

If your family member also has SDA funding, that contributes to the accommodation cost. But it's still not "all taken care of". Budgeting for SIL does require some planning, and families who go in knowing this are in a better position. We're not saying this to discourage you. We're saying it because families who understand the full picture from the start make better decisions. The Supported Independent Living Costs Budget Breakdown 2026 has a clear, detailed breakdown of what participants actually pay and what NDIS funding covers.

Myth 5: Once You're in SIL, You're Locked In

This fear keeps some families from exploring SIL at all. The worry is that signing up means committing to a permanent arrangement with a provider they may not connect with, in a setting they may not love.

SIL is reviewed as part of your family member's NDIS plan review, which typically happens every 12 months. If their support needs change, the SIL funding can be adjusted accordingly. Participants can also change SIL providers if the arrangement isn't working.

To be honest about the practical reality: changing SIL providers does involve a process. There are notice periods, handover coordination, and paperwork. It is not as simple as cancelling a subscription. But it is absolutely possible, and the fear of being permanently stuck should not be the reason your family member misses out on support they genuinely need.

From 1 July 2026, all SIL providers will also be required to register with the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission, raising the standard of oversight across the sector. Choosing well from the start helps. Our 30 questions to ask any SIL provider is designed for exactly that purpose.

Myth 6: SIL Means Living With Strangers in a Group Home

The image many families carry is of a large institution: shared bedrooms, rigid routines, and no say in who lives nearby. For families who remember what disability housing looked like before the NDIS, this fear is rooted in real experience.

Modern SIL arrangements look very different. SIL funding is available across a range of living settings. Some people receive SIL support while living alone. Others live in smaller shared arrangements, perhaps with one or two people they have met through the matching process, in homes that feel nothing like an institution.

The living arrangement and the SIL funding are separate decisions. Your family member can have SIL support in their own home or in an SDA property. They are not automatically placed anywhere.

For context on what this looks like in practice: our SDA properties across suburban Melbourne are typically smaller-scale homes in residential neighbourhoods, not large facilities. Your family member would choose their own SIL provider to support them in that home. If you want to see what these homes look like, you can browse our SDA homes to get a sense of the settings we work in.

The Fears Are Understandable. The Situation Has Changed.

These myths often come from older models of disability housing, complex NDIS language, or stories that were accurate years ago and no longer reflect current practice. That doesn't make the hesitation irrational. It makes it human.

If your family member has significant support needs and you have been putting off exploring SIL because of one of these concerns, it is worth taking another look. The system is not perfect, but it is substantially different from what many families imagine.

Paramount provides SDA housing, not SIL services. We can't help your family member apply for SIL or choose a provider. But if you want to talk through what the SDA housing side of the equation looks like, and what it means to find a home your family member actually wants to live in, we're here for that conversation.

Call us on (03) 9999 7418 or email admin@paramounthomes.com.au. We're happy to talk through your situation and point you in the right direction.

The goal is not to push anyone toward SIL. It's to make sure uncertainty isn't the reason your family member misses out on support they genuinely need.

NDIS Resources:

Related Reading: